Eggnog Overnight Oats Recipe | We are not Martha (2024)

Eggnog season is short lived, so you better get your fill of it while you can! These Eggnog Overnight Oats give you the perfect excuse to indulge in eggnog for breakfast.

Can you believe Christmas is in one week?? And then... the holiday season will officially be over. Which also means that eggnog season will be over. And I am so not ready for that.

But I guess that just means that I need to fit as much of it in as I possibly can over the next seven days. Without making myself so sick that I hate it forever. Because really, I feel like eggnog and candy corn are very similar in that once you take it too far, it's over forever.

So don't worry, I'm just over here enjoying my eggnog for breakfast. Overnight oats style.

Seriously though, I feel like Eggnog Overnight Oats are the perfect way to start your day off really well without going overboard. Right?? Please help me justify having eggnog for breakfast.

I guess these Christmas overnight oats are one of the reasons why eggnog season doesn't last long. Sigh.

Eggnog Overnight Oats Recipe

Anyway, I promise that this really is a toned down way of getting your eggnog fix. I only used ¼ cup of eggnog, along with ¼ cup of almond milk. Of course, if you want to go all out, feel free to use ½ cup eggnog and go on your holly jolly way.

Actually, the first time I made these eggnog overnight oats, I only had vanilla flavored Greek yogurt and I used all eggnog and let's just say it was a little tooo much sweetness for first thing in the morning.

So, I did some adjusting and came up with this perfect balance.

You don't have to add any toppings, but a little bit of crushed pecans and candy canes never hurt anyone, right? It is the holiday season, after all.

I love breakfasts like this because you prep them at night (when you're already begrudgingly prepping your lunch and making the coffee anyway) and then just grab them in the morning. The less you have to think in the morning, the better, right?

And if you're off to work at the office, you can throw your jar of eggnog overnight oats in your bag and eat it when you arrive. Or on your commute if you can't wait. Which you probably can't.

Just a warning that if you take public transportation, everyone will be pretty jealous to see you digging into a jar of Christmas overnight oats!

Despite the fact that these overnight oats involve eggnog, they're actually pretty healthy. Old fashioned oats are known to prevent cardiovascular disease and control blood sugar levels.

The chia seeds pack a nutrient punch; they're high in antioxidants, protein, and fiber and low in calories.

And the Greek yogurt is full of calcium, protein, and probiotics.

The eggnog? Well, that just helps the overnight oats stay super creamy and filled with holiday flavor.

I'm just happy I now have a legitimate excuse to have eggnog in the morning. You know, in addition to putting it in my coffee (really, I only ever drink my coffee black, unless there's eggnog involved).

Hey, it's only a few weeks a year and there's no better way to get into the holiday spirit.

But do you think eggnog would freeze well? Asking for a friend.

Have you had your fill of eggnog this holiday season?

If you need more excuses to get your fill of eggnog in before the holidays are over, try my Gingerbread Rolls with Eggnog Glaze or Snow Day Sugar Cookie Milkshake! I also can't wait to make these Oreo Eggnog Cheesecake Bars from Table for Seven!

📖 Recipe

More Breakfast Recipes